A.G. Concerned About Potential For Lawsuit Against “Deportation” of FSM Citizens


Although Governor Eddie Calvo has specifically ordered the “deportation” of criminals like Ninton Hauk via an Executive Order the Attorney General says Calvo is not technically deporting them but rather commuting their sentences as only the federal government has the authority to deport people.

Guam – Although Governor Eddie Calvo has specifically used the word deport in his executive order he does not have the ability to deport compact migrants. Instead it appears that he is brokering deals with criminals in which he commutes or lowers their sentence in exchange for the promise that they never return. Is this even enforceable? The Attorney General of Guam says she’s not sure.


“Deportation is a very complicated administrative adjudicatory process that really falls under the realm of the federal government,” said A.G. Elizabeth Barrett-Anderson. Although Governor Eddie Calvo has specifically ordered the deportation of criminals like Ninton Hauk via an Executive Order the Attorney General says he is not technically deporting them as only the federal government has the authority to deport people as it is the federal government that handles Guam’s immigration.


In his executive order the Governor cites residual authority “to enforce the immigration laws of the United States in default of performance by the immigration and naturalization service of the United States.” However the A.G. points out that, “and the Governor in the executive order was using a 64 year old court case and it has no application today. So I’m putting this concept that the Governor has residual deportation authority I’m putting that to the side and indicating that I don’t agree with him at that.”


The Attorney General instead believes that the Governor only has the authority to commute or lessen the sentences of inmates. “The Governor said I will commute your sentence on condition that you leave Guam and never return so that then to me became like a contract an agreement with the inmate,” said the A.G.


The problem is it’s not clear if this agreement is even enforceable. This is something the A.G. is currently looking into. “That’s actually what I’m looking at right now. I’m going to be meeting with the Chief of Customs the Director of Customs and to see whether the Governor’s office has given that agency any guidance,” said Barrett-Anderson.


PNC received a message from a Chuukese woman who said the father of her child is currently in prison on Guam while she and her family are currently living in California. She was concerned that he may be deported back to Chuuk. She asked PNC that if he were deported back to Chuuk could her family then buy him a ticket to join them in California?


“And I can’t answer that question for the individual the documents that the Governor has these inmates sign doesn’t just include re-entry into Guam but transit through Guam. It also informs the airlines. I don’t know what obligation the airlines has to our executive orders and again I don’t know what obligation the federal government has to our executive orders,” said Barrett-Anderson.


In essence this poses the question as to whether or not the Governor of Guam has the right to ban an immigrant from re-entering not just Guam but the entire U.S.


It’s these types of questions that has the A.G. concerned about GovGuam’s liability. “You mentioned that you don’t want it to come back and bite us in the hand in what way could that happen?” asked PNC. “A lawsuit. A lawsuit filed from many different directions and part of what I do here as Attorney General is defend the general fund defend our coffers against lawsuits,” said Barrett-Anderson.


The Attorney General says that she will look into this entire issue and if she finds that there is something that may be unenforceable she will recommend that the program be suspended.




  1. If these immigrants are allowed to migrate here for schooling and/or employment, we welcome them. If they’re here to sponge off the federal governments numerous programs such as WIC or QUEST or to live a life of crime, i say time to show them the way to go home.

Comments are closed.